A data-driven approach to patent prosecution

Thomas Gibb

Close-up of colourful computer code on a screen, with syntax highlighting in shades of blue, orange, and yellow.

Companies have used data analytics to drive many aspects of their patent strategy.

Patent landscaping can be used to identify gaps in the market where a new entrant may obtain significant patent protection. Additionally, competitor analysis can highlight increases in patent activity in new sectors and markets, or highlight withdrawals and abandonments indicative of a competitor’s change in commercial focus.

Using data when prosecuting patent applications

Proprietary tools can also be used to indicate the strength and value of individual patent rights, or a portfolio as a whole. However, despite these developments, one area where data has been historically underused is in the prosecution of patent applications themselves. Ask any European patent attorney, and they will be able to regale you with anecdotes about an ‘impossible examiner’, as well as other applications where the journey to grant was perhaps smoother than expected. Much like patent applications, every examiner is different.

Despite this fact, historically, there has been little consideration of the propensities of the examiner by patent attorneys or applicants. Often the view is that, as the examiner cannot be changed, you should make the best of the situation at hand. However, the use of data during prosecution can improve the chances of progressing an application to grant, especially in the most difficult cases.

How to use data in patent prosecution

Firstly, data can be used to provide an informed view of the challenge presented by any one examiner. Data can be used to compare an examiner’s grant rate to others within their IPC sector. In this way, taken alongside the application’s content and the known prior art, a picture of the potential progression of examination can begin to emerge. Accordingly, if progressing the application looks potentially challenging, the applicant can be advised that there is a reasonable chance that an appeal may be required before any grant, for example.

Beyond this, it is also possible to study the outcome of oral proceedings for cases handled by any one examiner. Oral proceedings in examination can come at a significant cost, so applicants are always keen to determine the chances of a successful outcome and patent grant. Data-driven prosecution strategies consider the result of previous examination oral proceedings in cases handled by the examiner in question. Subsequently, this data can be used to advise if attending oral proceedings is likely to be successful, or if moving to appeal or the filing of a divisional patent application may be preferred.

An advanced data-driven approach to patent prosecution

A further, more advanced, data-driven approach can also be employed when responding to specific objections raised by an examiner. The historic objections raised by each examiner are publically available, as are the responses to each of those objections. This data can be interrogated to determine which arguments are the most successful in persuading specific examiners to withdraw each kind of objection. Using such a data-driven approach in response to the objections raised by an examiner can be very powerful in progressing applications and achieving grant, even in the most challenging cases.

Adopting and embracing a data-driven approach allows applicants to optimise the prosecution of their patent applications, increasing the chance of success and ensuring the effective targeting of resources throughout the application process.

If you would like more information, please contact us.

The logos of the Financial Times and Statista are shown, with the FT logo featuring black text on a cream background and the Statista logo in dark blue.
A hexagonal badge with the text "10+ YEARS IP STARS RANKED from Managing IP" in navy and gold on a cream background.
The logo features the words "The Legal 500" in stylised black and grey text with a modern, sleek design.
The IAM 300 logo features bold red and black text with a stylised red graphic element on a white background.
Text on a logo that reads "IAM 300 GLOBAL LEADERS 2025" with a design element of red three horizontal bars on the left.
The logo features stylised red lines, the text "IAM" in bold black and red, and "1000" underneath, set against a plain background.
WTR 1000 logo in various shades of blue, gold, and black, with a geometric design and text on a transparent background.
The image displays the Lexology Client and Industry News logo with a pattern of dark circles and the words "LEXOLOGY" and "INDUSTRY NEWS".
A round emblem with a gold eagle and the text "IP Eagle Talents 2024", surrounded by a gold border and a red ribbon with Chinese characters.
Logo of DéCIDEURS MAGAZINE featuring three shooting stars inside a circle and the magazine name in bold black and red text.
WIPR 2024 logo highlighting Diversity, with the tagline "Influential Woman in IP" on a teal background.
The Legal Benchmarking Social Impact Awards 2024 logo features a purple circle with "LBG" and bold black text to the right.
A colourful four-petal flower logo with a dark circle in the centre, accompanied by the text "IP INCLUSIVE" and the tagline "Working for diversity and inclusion in IP".
A colourful abstract logo with interconnected circles and the text "ADAPT.legal" underneath, set against a dark grey background.
European Patent Pipeline Program logo with the acronym "EPPP" in large pink letters above the full name in smaller dark blue text.
LSA logo with green text and leaf design, accompanied by black text reading "Legal Sustainability Alliance" and "Member | 2024".
A close-up of a cybersecurity badge featuring a blue background, green check mark, and the words "Cyber Essentials Certified."
A Cyber Essentials Plus logo featuring a blue and green circular emblem with a tick mark, accompanied by the text "CYBER ESSENTIALS PLUS".
The logo features the word "oveda" with a stylised, multicoloured swoosh design and the slogan “Invested in a better future” underneath.
Green and black logo featuring a stylised globe with wavy lines and the text "United Kingdom Best Managed Companies" beside it.